The FA Cup third round once again proved why it remains the world’s most captivating knockout competition. Across a thrilling weekend in January 2026, 30 ties delivered 124 goals—an average of 4.1 per game—marking the highest tally in nearly 70 years. Giant-killings, dramatic finishes, and packed away ends reaffirmed the tournament’s magic, even amid modern changes like scrapped replays.
A Goal Fest for the Ages
This round ranks among the most prolific since the third-round format standardised in 1925-26. Only three previous editions exceeded the 124 goals scored (excluding wartime anomalies), with the record standing at 138 from 1926-27.
Standout scorelines included Manchester City’s 10-1 demolition of Exeter City and Wolverhampton Wanderers’ 6-0 rout of Shrewsbury Town. Chelsea, Burnley, Bristol City, Burton Albion, and Norwich City each netted five, while Mansfield Town edged a seven-goal thriller against Sheffield United.
Four hat-tricks—the most in 14 years—added individual brilliance. Wrexham and Newcastle United advanced via penalties after entertaining 3-3 draws.
Historical Goal Tallies in FA Cup Third Round
| Season | Total Goals | Average per Game | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1926-27 | 138 | Highest record | Pre-war era |
| 1946-47 | 128 | Post-war | Two-legged ties excluded |
| 1956-57 | 128 | Post-war peak | |
| 2025-26 | 124 | Modern high | 30 ties played |
These figures highlight a return to free-scoring entertainment, captivating fans worldwide.
Macclesfield’s Monumental Upset
The weekend’s defining moment came at Moss Rose, where sixth-tier Macclesfield FC stunned defending champions Crystal Palace 2-1. The 117-place league gap makes this the largest upset in FA Cup history.
Macclesfield dominated deservedly, becoming the first non-league side to eliminate holders since Crystal Palace’s 1908-09 win over Wolves. It was only the ninth non-league top-flight victory in a century.
The reformed club’s rapid rise—from ninth tier post-2020 collapse to National League North contenders—adds fairytale depth. Fans’ pitch invasion celebrated a moment etched in folklore.
Fan Power Fuels the Atmosphere
Away allocations up to 15% transformed grounds into cauldrons. Aston Villa brought 9,000 to Tottenham, Exeter nearly 8,000 to Manchester City, and Sunderland 7,732 to Everton. Leeds filled over 5,000 seats at Derby, while Weston-super-Mare’s 600 backed their near-upset at Grimsby.
These vibrant travelling contingents underscored the cup’s unique appeal, contrasting routine league matches.
VAR Absence and Replay Changes
Technology arrives only from the fifth round, ensuring consistency for lower-tier clubs. The weekend passed without major refereeing controversies overshadowing results.
Scrapping replays eased fixture congestion for top clubs but drew lower-league criticism over lost revenue. Premier League sides averaged 6.4 changes—up from last season—yet no lower-tier team lost a potential replay on penalties against higher opposition (except MK Dons to Oxford United).
Wrexham benefited, eliminating Nottingham Forest via shootout.
Why the FA Cup Endures
This third round blended tradition with spectacle: record goals, historic shocks, passionate support, and drama. Macclesfield’s triumph embodies the competition’s essence—opportunity for all.
As fourth-round draws loom, anticipation builds. The FA Cup’s romance thrives, delivering stories that transcend generations.
