Ashes Player Ratings: Stunning Performances & Disappointing Struggles
The stage was set for one of the most thrilling Test series in recent memory—an epic battle that had fans on the edge of their seats until the final ball. For the first time in two decades, all five matches stretched into the fifth day, pushing England’s squad to their physical and mental limits. Though they narrowly missed out on series victory, the performances offered plenty of excitement—and a few questions—ahead of the upcoming Ashes in Australia.
With just months remaining before the battle resumes down under, England’s selectors face tough decisions. Some players have staked undeniable claims for a spot, while others left doubts hanging in the air. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of how England’s key performers fared—and what it means for their Ashes prospects.
—
Top Order: Sparks of Brilliance Amid Inconsistency
Ben Duckett – 8/10
Duckett’s explosive 149 in the first Test was a masterclass in batting aggression, setting the tone for England’s dominance early in the series. Though he couldn’t convert subsequent starts into centuries, his ability to provide rapid-fire openings was crucial. His growing leadership presence and fearless approach against the new ball make him indispensable ahead of the Ashes, where his adaptability against Australia’s pace attack will be tested.
Zak Crawley – 5/10
A tale of two halves for Crawley—flashes of elegance, but an average that mirrored his career figures (32.22). While the stats aren’t flattering, his partnership with Duckett remains England’s preferred opening combination. The faster, bouncier tracks in Australia could either expose his flaws or, optimistically, unlock the potential that England’s management continues to believe in.
Ollie Pope – 5/10
A rollercoaster series for Pope, whose dazzling 106 in the second innings at Lord’s was followed by a string of underwhelming scores. His second-innings struggles (averaging just 19.8) raise concerns about his ability to anchor England’s top order. If a contender like Dan Lawrence or an in-form county star shines in the lead-up, Pope’s No. 3 spot may not be as secure as he hopes.
—
Middle Order: England’s Dependables Shine
Joe Root – 9.5/10
If there were doubts about Root’s class, he put them to rest emphatically. With 537 runs, three centuries, and an average of 67.1, he was England’s batting backbone. His graceful strokeplay and ability to counterattack under pressure were invaluable. However, he has unfinished business in Australia—where he is yet to score a Test hundred. If England are to reclaim the Ashes, Root must deliver his best on the biggest stage.
Harry Brook – 8.5/10
Brook announced himself as England’s next superstar with two centuries and a near-miss 99. His fearless approach against both pace and spin was a revelation, and his ability to shift gears under pressure makes him a must-pick for the Ashes. Australia’s bowlers will target him, but if he maintains his form, he could be the difference-maker.
Ben Stokes – 9/10 (Captain & All-Rounder)
Stokes silenced any doubts about his fitness with a monumental all-round performance. His match-defining 141 in Manchester and 17 wickets reaffirmed his status as England’s heartbeat. His leadership was equally crucial—when he was absent in the final Test, England looked rudderless. If a single player’s fitness could swing the Ashes, it’s Stokes.
—
Bowling Attack: High Pace, High Stakes
Josh Tongue – 6.5/10
Despite playing only three Tests, Tongue emerged as England’s leading wicket-taker (19 scalps). Though inconsistent at times, his knack for breaking partnerships keeps him in contention. He’ll need to sharpen his control for Australia, but his raw pace could be an asset.
Jofra Archer – 8/10
Archer’s return was worth the wait—nine wickets in two Tests and bowling spells that reminded everyone why he’s feared worldwide. If England can keep him fit, his sheer speed and bounce could terrorize Australia’s batsmen.
Chris Woakes – 5.5/10
Woakes battled valiantly, even batting with a shoulder injury in the final Test. However, his bowling returns (11 wickets at 52.1) suggest he may no longer be at his peak. Injury concerns might rule him out of the Ashes, opening the door for younger quicks.
Gus Atkinson – 7.5/10
After a quiet start, Atkinson’s 8-wicket haul at The Oval was a reminder of his skill. His accuracy and ability to extract movement make him a dark horse for the Ashes, particularly on Australia’s lively tracks.
—
The Underachievers & Wildcards
Jamie Smith – 7/10
His brilliant 184 at Edgbaston was one of the highlights of the summer, but a late dip raised concerns. If he can regain consistency, he’s a long-term asset for England.
Jacob Bethell – 3/10
Thrust into the side with little preparation, Bethell looked out of his depth. However, England’s selectors clearly see long-term potential—strong performances in white-ball cricket might revive his Ashes hopes.
Shoaib Bashir – 6/10
Expensive but effective, Bashir’s attacking spin earned him wickets. With no clear standout spinner, he could still be in the mix for Australia.
—
Predicted Ashes XI: Who Makes the Cut?
With no warm-up matches before November, England’s lineup is already a hot debate. Here’s how experts see it:
– Jonathan Agnew: Crawley, Duckett, Pope, Root, Brook, Stokes (c), Smith, Atkinson, Carse, Archer, Wood
– Michael Vaughan: Same XI, but Carse or Tongue as the third seamer
– Ebony Rainford-Brent: Bashir in for a spinner option
– Sir Alastair Cook: Favors Carse over Tongue for extra control
One thing is clear—England must fine-tune their squad before the Ashes, or they risk falling short again against Australia’s battle-hardened side.
Which players do you think deserve a spot? Let us know your thoughts!
—
Related: England Men’s Cricket Team, Cricket, The Ashes, Test Cricket
