Top Manchester United Strikers: Watkins & Sesko vs Hojlund – Best Comparison
Manchester United’s hunt for a clinical striker has intensified, with Ollie Watkins and Benjamin Sesko emerging as prime targets. Both players could offer an upgrade over Rasmus Hojlund, whose debut season was marked by flashes of brilliance but inconsistent finishing. As the transfer window heats up, the Red Devils face a crucial decision—stick with Hojlund’s potential, pursue the Premier League-proven Watkins, or invest in Sesko’s sky-high upside?
Manchester United’s Striker Dilemma: Why Watkins and Sesko Are in Demand
Last season exposed Manchester United’s reliance on an unreliable goalscoring department. Despite Hojlund’s physicality and work rate, his four Premier League goals in 32 appearances were not enough to elevate the team’s attack. In contrast, Watkins (16 goals for Aston Villa) and Sesko (13 for RB Leipzig) delivered far more consistent returns. Their profiles fit different needs—Watkins brings instant impact, while Sesko offers long-term promise.
United’s financial constraints complicate matters. To fund a marquee signing, they must first offload fringe players, meaning any deal could drag toward deadline day. Yet, with Erik ten Hag demanding reinforcements, the club must weigh their options carefully.
Benjamin Sesko: The Ideal Long-Term Investment for Manchester United
Sesko isn’t just a traditional target man—he’s a modern, multi-faceted striker. At 6’5, his aerial prowess is obvious, but he combines it with surprising speed, technical quality, and an eye for spectacular goals. Unlike Hojlund, who often struggles with link-up play, Sesko thrives when receiving the ball in deep positions or sprinting onto through passes.
– Key Strengths:
– Versatility in attack (hold-up play, runs in behind)
– Superior goal contribution (13 goals in 33 Bundesliga games)
– Better creative numbers than Hojlund (higher xG, shot-creating actions)
Leipzig’s £87m valuation is steep, but Sesko’s ceiling justifies the investment. With Newcastle also circling, United must act swiftly to secure his signature.
Ollie Watkins: The Premier League-Proven Contender
Watkins would offer an immediate fix—a seasoned Premier League finisher with intelligence on and off the ball. His 16-goal haul for Aston Villa last season highlighted his composure in front of goal, while his movement and pressing align perfectly with Ten Hag’s system.
However, prying him away from Villa Park won’t be easy. His contract runs until 2028, and the club will demand a premium—likely exceeding £60m. At 29, he also lacks the resale value Sesko provides.
– Key Strengths:
– Reliable goal output (16 in 38 league matches)
– Premier League experience and adaptability
– Strong work rate and pressing ability
How Do They Compare to Rasmus Hojlund?
Hojlund’s debut campaign was a tale of unfulfilled promise. While his physicality and energy impressed, his finishing let him down. A deeper look at the stats reveals a stark contrast:
– Hojlund (2023-24):
– 4 goals in 32 Premier League games
– Struggled with consistency in link-up play
– Low shot conversion rate compared to Watkins and Sesko
– Sesko & Watkins (2023-24):
– More goals, better creativity, and higher involvement in buildup
If United seek immediate results, Watkins is the safer bet. But if they’re building for the future, Sesko’s potential makes him the superior choice.
The Verdict: Who Should Manchester United Sign?
Watkins guarantees Premier League pedigree, but his age and price tag raise concerns. Sesko, meanwhile, is a high-upside gamble who could become one of Europe’s elite strikers. Hojlund remains a project—one that may need time United can’t afford.
With the window closing soon, Ten Hag must decide: Does he prioritize experience or potential? One thing is certain—Manchester United need a striker who can deliver goals consistently, and both Watkins and Sesko fit the bill better than Hojlund—for now.
As the clock ticks, the hierarchy’s choice will shape United’s attack for seasons to come. Will they opt for proven quality or a future star? The answer could define their upcoming campaign.
