Premier League Predictions 2025-26: BBC Sport Pundits Pick Their Top Four
As the 2025-26 Premier League season approaches, football fans and analysts are buzzing with anticipation. Last season saw Liverpool claim a surprising but dominant title victory, finishing 10 points ahead of runners-up Arsenal. Now, the big question looms: Can the Reds defend their crown, or will the chasing pack close the gap?
With Manchester City eager to reclaim supremacy, Arsenal aiming to finally break their near-decade-long title drought, and Chelsea building on their progress, the battle at the top promises to be fiercer than ever. To break it all down, we’ve gathered insights from 32 BBC Sport pundits, along with predictions from AI and Opta’s Supercomputer.
The Methodology Behind the Predictions
Before diving into the expert opinions, it’s worth noting how these predictions were compiled.
– Human Pundits: A panel of former players, managers, and analysts provided their top-four forecasts, along with reasoned explanations.
– AI Prediction: Generated using Microsoft Copilot Chat, the AI was simply asked: Predict the Premier League table for the 2025-26 season.
– Opta Supercomputer: A sophisticated algorithm that factors in betting market odds and Opta’s own Power Rankings, simulating all 380 Premier League fixtures 10,000 times to generate the most probable outcome.
Interestingly, the Supercomputer aligned with 12 of the BBC pundits—including Chris Sutton, who follows a similar methodology for his weekly predictions.
So, what do the experts foresee? Let’s break it down team by team.
—
Liverpool – Can the Champions Defend Their Crown?
Liverpool’s resurgence under Arne Slot was one of the stories of last season, with their 10-point margin over Arsenal silencing doubters. This time, 21 out of 34 pundits back them to retain the title.
Key Takeaways:
– Transfer Market Moves: The potential signing of Alexander Isak has been hotly debated. If they get Isak, give them the title straight away, said Steve Sidwell.
– Defensive Concerns: Virgil van Dijk’s age (34) and the integration of new full-backs could test their backline.
– Midfield Strength: Florian Wirtz’s arrival adds creativity, but balance remains a question.
Alan Shearer summed it up: Liverpool are favourites, even without Isak. Just look at last season—they won it at a canter.
—
Arsenal – Time to End the Wait?
The Gunners have finished second in the last three campaigns. Mikel Arteta’s side came closer than ever last season, but can they take the final step?
Key Takeaways:
– Striker Solution? With Viktor Gyökeres signed, Arsenal finally have a focal point up front. Thomas Hitzlsperger noted: They have the striker they’ve been missing.
– Young Talents Rising: Teenagers Myles Lewis-Skelly and Ethan Nwaneri have gained valuable experience, adding depth.
– Big-Game Mentality: Their early-season fixtures (including Liverpool and Man City) will be a true test.
Chris Waddle cautioned: If Gyökeres hits the ground running, they can win it—but Arteta is under pressure to deliver.
—
Manchester City – Can Pep Bounce Back?
A wounded animal is always dangerous—and after surrendering their four-year Premier League reign, Man City are out for revenge. However, only 18% of pundits still see them lifting the trophy.
Key Takeaways:
– New Faces, New Style: Pep Guardiola has refreshed his squad, but losing stalwarts like Kevin De Bruyne changes their dynamics.
– Erling Haaland’s Return: The Norwegian remains the most lethal striker in the world.
– Midfield Reinforcement: Rodri’s return from injury is like a new signing.
Paul Robinson warned: A wounded City are dangerous—Pep has a point to prove.
—
Chelsea – Champions of the World, But Can They Conquer England?
After winning the Club World Cup and securing a top-four finish, Chelsea are pushing for more. While most pundits have them fourth, some believe they could be genuine contenders.
Key Takeaways:
– Depth and Youth Talent: Signings like João Pedro add firepower, but defensive issues linger.
– Enzo Maresca’s Tactical Shift: A clear playing identity is emerging, but will it hold up against the league’s elite?
– Fatigue Factor: The Club World Cup exertions could take a toll later in the season.
Rachel Brown-Finnis boldly claimed: I’d be shocked if they don’t win at least one trophy.
—
The Verdict: A Four-Horse Race with Little Room for Surprises
This season’s predictions have a remarkable lack of variation—only four teams (Liverpool, Arsenal, Man City, and Chelsea) were named in every pundit’s top-four picks. The last time this happened was in 2015-16—the year Leicester City defied 5000/1 odds to win the title. Could history repeat itself?
Alan Shearer isn’t convinced: The top four have strengthened so much that the chasing pack will struggle to break in.
Final Consensus Rankings (Average Points Based on Predictions):
1. Liverpool (121 pts)
2. Arsenal (90 pts)
3. Manchester City (83 pts)
4. Chelsea (46 pts)
—
What About the Rest?
For Manchester United, Tottenham, Newcastle, and Aston Villa, breaking into the top four appears a daunting task. Chris Sutton noted: United’s lack of European football is an advantage, but they’re still rebuilding.
Meanwhile, Everton’s signing of Jack Grealish has raised eyebrows, but as Paul Robinson said, They won’t crack the top four, but they could challenge for Europe.
Do You Agree? Make Your Own Prediction
With the window still open, much could change. Would you back Liverpool to dominate again? Could Arsenal finally end their drought? Or will Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City reclaim their throne?
One thing is certain—the 2025-26 Premier League season will be unmissable.
