England’s Six Nations 2026 campaign reached a new low on March 7, 2026, as they suffered a shocking 18-23 defeat to Italy at Stadio Olimpico in Rome. This result marked Italy’s first-ever win against England in the competition’s history, plunging Steve Borthwick’s side into deeper crisis after three consecutive losses.
With one round remaining, England sit fifth in the standings with one win from four matches (107 points scored, 103 conceded, +4 difference, 6 points total). France lead with 16 points, followed closely by Scotland and Ireland. A loss to France in Paris next weekend would see England record four defeats in a single Six Nations campaign for the first time, raising serious questions about Borthwick’s future.
A Turning Point in Rome: Discipline Derails England
England appeared in control midway through the second half, leading 18-10 after tries from Tommy Freeman and Tom Roebuck, plus Fin Smith’s conversions and penalties. However, two yellow cards shifted momentum decisively.
Flanker Sam Underhill received a sin-bin for a high tackle on Danilo Fischetti, allowing Paolo Garbisi to narrow the gap with penalties. Captain Maro Itoje followed shortly after for a cynical slap-down on Alessandro Garbisi at the breakdown, reducing England to 13 men briefly. Italy capitalized with Leonardo Marin’s late try (converted by Garbisi) to seal the victory. Tommaso Menoncello had earlier scored Italy’s first try.
Borthwick highlighted the impact: “I thought at 60 minutes we had the game under control, but going down to 13 men hurt us badly.” Discipline has plagued England throughout the tournament—yellow cards for Henry Pollock, Freddie Steward, Henry Arundell (twice, leading to a red card period), Tom Curry, and now Underhill and Itoje (his second of the campaign).
Matt Dawson, a Rugby World Cup winner, criticized Itoje’s decision: “He will be furious with himself… it’s absolutely unacceptable.” The captain accepted responsibility post-match: “The coaches set us up to do well, and we as players have to take responsibility.”
Broader Issues: Shapeless Attack and Tactical Concerns
Discipline aside, England’s attack lacked cohesion. Even with possession, they failed to stretch Italy’s defense, relying heavily on aerial contests. While Cadan Murley secured early territory, the strategy yielded inconsistent results. Italy, by contrast, showed cunning variety in their kicking game and physicality through Menoncello.
Dawson questioned the overall approach: “Questions need to be asked about England’s strategy and methodology… The way England are playing, they are not going to win international matches.” The high-kick-heavy, low-flair style has frustrated fans, eroding patience now that results have dried up.
Borthwick’s side won their opening match against Wales but have since fallen to Scotland, Ireland, and now Italy. This follows a 12-match winning streak that ended recently, highlighting the rapid decline.
Borthwick’s Defense and the RFU Dilemma
Post-match, Borthwick insisted he remains the right man: “Absolutely.” He emphasized recent growth, emerging players, and ongoing discussions with RFU leadership about the team’s vision. “The team’s growth in the last 12 months has been very, very strong… Right now this is a tough period, but what we will do is learn from it.”
The RFU faces a difficult choice. Changing coaches late in a World Cup cycle proved costly under Eddie Jones before 2023. Borthwick guided England close to the final despite limited preparation time, earning credit for stability.
Yet scrutiny intensifies. Potential successors include Scott Robertson (recently departed from New Zealand), Franco Smith (successful at Glasgow), Pat Lam (Bristol), Andy Farrell, Shaun Edwards, and Phil Dowson (Northampton). Each carries risks, but the status quo also draws doubts.
Looking Ahead: France Awaits in Paris
England’s next challenge is France away—formidable opponents at altitude. A fourth loss would compound the crisis ahead of summer tours and beyond.
Italy’s triumph represents a landmark for Italian rugby, but for England, it underscores systemic issues. Borthwick must rally his squad, restore discipline, and rediscover attacking spark. Whether this defeat signals the beginning of the end for his tenure depends on swift improvement—or further decline.
As the Six Nations 2026 concludes, England’s future direction hangs in the balance. Fans demand answers, and the RFU must decide if Borthwick can deliver them.
