Manchester United’s search for stability following Ruben Amorim’s dismissal has spotlighted two familiar faces: Michael Carrick and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. As of January 7, 2026, the former players are frontrunners for the caretaker manager position until season’s end, with face-to-face talks imminent. This development offers a blend of club legacy and proven transitional experience as United navigate another challenging chapter.
The Context of the Vacancy
Amorim’s 14-month tenure ended abruptly on January 5, 2026, after inconsistent results and reported internal tensions. Darren Fletcher, the current Under-18s coach and club legend, assumed interim duties immediately. He will lead the team for the Premier League trip to Burnley on January 8 (20:15 GMT) and likely the FA Cup third-round clash with Brighton.
Club sources indicate flexibility in the caretaker setup—one individual, a shared role, or even extending Fletcher’s stint if early results impress. A permanent manager is targeted for summer 2026, aligning with a broader restructuring under INEOS ownership.
Why Carrick and Solskjaer Lead the Race
Both candidates embody Manchester United DNA, having contributed as players and coaches during pivotal eras.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer famously stepped in as caretaker after Jose Mourinho’s 2018 sacking. His initial impact—transforming a struggling side into contenders—earned a permanent role lasting three years. Highlights included a second-place Premier League finish in 2020-21 and a Europa League final appearance. Though trophyless at United, his tenure provided stability post-Sir Alex Ferguson.
Michael Carrick served as a key assistant under Solskjaer before a brief three-game interim spell in 2021, remaining unbeaten (two wins, one draw). His subsequent permanent role at Middlesbrough demonstrated steady progress, guiding the club to play-offs in 2022-23.
A collaborative model appeals, given Carrick’s integral role in Solskjaer’s staff. Ruud van Nistelrooy, another former striker, remains a contender, adding to the pool of club icons under consideration.
Managerial Records Comparison
| Manager | Total Games Managed | Win Rate | Key Achievements at United | Recent Experience |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ole Gunnar Solskjaer | ~500+ | 53.1% | Caretaker success (2018); Permanent role (2019-2021); Europa League final; 2nd in PL | Managed Besiktas (Jan-Aug 2025); Sacked after 29 games |
| Michael Carrick | ~170 | 46.8% | Interim unbeaten (2021); Assistant under Solskjaer | Middlesbrough (2022-June 2025); Play-offs 2022-23; Sacked after missing top six |
Solskjaer’s extensive CV includes Norwegian titles with Molde and a challenging spell at Cardiff. Carrick’s shorter but solid record at Middlesbrough showcased tactical acumen in the Championship.
Early Contenders for Permanent Role
While the caretaker focuses on short-term results, names like Crystal Palace’s Oliver Glasner—fresh from an FA Cup triumph—and Marseille’s Roberto de Zerbi have surfaced for the summer position. Glasner dismissed speculation on January 7, reaffirming commitment to Palace.
What This Means for United
Appointing Carrick, Solskjaer, or a combination leverages institutional knowledge during transition. Players reportedly favour familiar figures who understand Old Trafford’s demands. Positive early performances could influence the caretaker’s duration, mirroring Solskjaer’s 2018 trajectory.
Supporters crave stability after recent upheavals. These candidates offer reassurance through shared history, potentially reigniting squad belief ahead of a demanding schedule.
As talks progress, Manchester United balances nostalgia with pragmatism. The caretaker choice could shape the club’s trajectory into the summer and beyond, providing a bridge to the next permanent era.
